One thing I have in common with archaeologists is being conscious of an artifact's context with the environment it is recovered in. Most metal detecting hobbyists, and bottle collectors are NOT interested in context; they are more impressed with the object itself, more than they are interested in the precise location and orientation of the object. Or even in general terms. This is a shame, because, archaeologists are correct when they say the object's piece of the puzzle, or context, is lost forever once it is removed from it's resting place.
Simple, home-made tools: computer-printed in and cm scale and North reference on the handle of a cleaning brush |
Handheld GPS unit, or the GPS app in your phone will give you geo location data |
computer-printed size reference scale on my Garrett Pro Pointer II |
Keeping a record of significant finds is not a liability, it is an asset! No one is asking you to take out an ad and publicize your find...it is your find, pure and simple. However, one day, when your young son or daughter or even grandchildren, wander over to you with it, and ask "What's THIS Grandpa?" what are you gonna' say? Maybe you'll say, "I don't know, let's take it to the museum and find out!"
Use a simple and cheap, pocket rolling ruler for depth measurements |
I think keeping records of significant finds will label us all as responsible metal detecting hobbyists, and not the looters of history we are sometimes made out to be. The tools to do so are not expensive and the work involved is minimal. If only we'll just do it! Time will tell if it was worth the effort or not.
Hi Jim:
ReplyDeleteBang on, mate! And well put.
If you keep your own record of finds from a particular site, you'll soon discover a 'pattern' of distribution. This could be indicative of a long-lost pathway (leading to where?) or even the site of a market place. Casual losses are what we do, and the spread of these losses in the top few inches of soil are the kind of data not collated by conventional archaeologists, they being, understandably, more concerned with ripping out the first few feet of topsoil t get tp the layers and context that holds the most interest for them.
Such private records are hugely important and have the potential to change conventional thinking on a particular area. The UK's government-funded Portable Antiquities Scheme acts as the collator for metal detecting finds, many of which are the launch pad for academic research.
Best
John H
Exactly my point, John. Everyone wants their cake and eat it too, so to speak, here in the U.S. which continues to draw fire from the archaeological lobby, and continues to be, not without cause, a sore point in denying access to metal detecting hobbyists. I think a small amount of responsible documentation and record keeping would go a long way in legitimizing metal detectorists in their own right. Thanks for commenting John!
ReplyDeleteThe US is no different to any other country where the more unbalanced (I have to say) and rabble 'anti' archaeologists are fighting hard for their rights to be recognised as THE unopposed heritage experts, a position which has been much eroded with the advent of very knowledgeable detectorists and treasure hunters.
ReplyDeleteThe only way they can protect their increasingly desperate position is either to :-
denigrate detectorists as academically ignorant;
or
engage in a desparate fact-free 'anti' propaganda campaign to persuade an often gullible media and local law-makers that metal detecting is somehow anti-social;
or
hide from the media view the huge steps being made in the UK with the Portable Antiquities Scheme (PAS).
If the stunning successes of the PAS can be shrouded from the US media, then the archaeological lobby might have a chance of outlawing the hobby. They, knowing that the US detecting lobby is less than weak and willing to offer any organised resistance they might not be so far from an outright detecting ban based on lies and half-truths.
I have been fighting these devils for over three decades. I know their tricks, deceits, and propaganda. As long as I have blood coursing through my veins, I'll never surrender to these jihadists.
Best
John